Welcome to the family- Fire Island!

Ok, we listened, we’re adding jalapenos to our menu! 

It’s been long overdue but it’s time we add a little spice to your life with our newest New York pie – Fire Island. 

Named after the thin Atlantic Ocean barrier island off the southern shore of Long Island, New York, Fire Island is the perfect blend of our Famous New York Pepperoni and the freshest jalapenos to give you that delicious kickstart into summer! You can also try them with any other pizza at Sal’s – Just add them as an extra topping!

Introducing our new Pepperoni and Jalapeno pizza – Fire Island 


The closest thing you’ll get to a heatwave anytime soon…